How to Vet a Brokerage Before You Join: 10 Questions to Ask After a Leadership Change

Hook: You joined—or you were courted by—a brokerage and then leadership changed. Now what?

Fast answer: Don’t sign, renew, or transfer until you run a targeted due diligence checklist that focuses on culture, compensation, tech, training programs, and career growth.

In 2026 the brokerage landscape is moving faster than most agents can track. Big-name leadership moves and mass agent conversions have continued through late 2025 and into 2026. Examples include high-profile CEO appointments at legacy brands and major conversions that shifted thousands of agents across networks. Those events promise fresh energy—and risk. If your brokerage just named a new CEO or absorbed a large agent conversion, use this guide to vet leadership shifts like a pro.

Why this matters now (short)

Consolidation and leadership churn accelerated in 2024–2025, and 2026 has further highlighted how rapidly strategic priorities can change after a CEO appointment or large conversion. New leaders bring new tech bets, compensation adjustments, office footprints, and culture resets. Agents who skip focused vetting face surprises: stalled commissions, lost MLS access, canceled training programs, or worse—non-compete headaches during a move.

How to use this checklist

Start with the ten questions below. For each question you’ll get: why it matters, what counts as a red flag, how to verify answers, and a short script you can use when talking to leadership, recruiting managers, or fellow agents. Track answers in a one-page due-diligence memo you keep for decisions and negotiations.

Quick vetting checklist (one-sentence version)

• Leadership vision & track record: ask for the 12–24 month strategic plan.
• Retention metrics: 12-month agent churn and conversion outcomes.
• Comp structure: splits, caps, fees, payout timing, and recent changes.
• Training & mentorship: curriculum, frequency, and outcomes.
• Tech stack & data ownership: platforms, integrations, and AI tools.
• Marketing & lead allocation: who pays and how leads are distributed.
• Career growth: promotion paths, revenue opportunities, and ownership options.
• Legal & compliance: contract changes, non-competes, and risk indemnities.
• Culture signals: performance reviews, DEI metrics, and hybrid policies.
• Financial health & support: marketing funds, brokerage solvency, and office budgets.

The 10 essential questions to ask after a CEO appointment or mass conversion

1. What is the CEO's 12–24 month strategic plan, and can I see it?

Why this matters: A CEO appointment often signals a change in priorities—tech investments, brand repositioning, M&A, or cost rationalization. Agents need to understand the direction and how it affects deals, splits, and tools.

Red flags: Vague answers, refusal to share measurable goals, or plans that prioritize consolidation over agent support.

How to verify: Ask for the strategic memo, town-hall recordings, or board presentation summaries. Compare with public statements and recent actions (hire/fires, product rollouts).

Script: 'Can you share the 12–24 month strategic priorities and expected changes for agent operations, compensation, and tech? I’m evaluating long-term fit.'

2. What are the retention and conversion metrics for the last 12 months?

Why this matters: Mass conversions and leadership changes create churn. Retention numbers show whether changes improve or erode agent satisfaction.

Red flags: No data, inconsistent metrics, or retention worse than peers in the same markets.

How to verify: Request agent retention rates, average tenure, and conversion outcomes (for converted teams). Check LinkedIn for agent attrition and office closures.

Script: 'Can you provide agent retention rates for the last 12 months and outcomes from any recent conversions? I’d like to understand agent stability.'

3. Have any compensation plans changed or are planned to change soon?

Why this matters: Compensation is the most tangible impact on your earnings. New leadership may alter splits, caps, fees, or add tiered models tied to production or tech usage.

Red flags: Retroactive changes, complex fee layering, or commission holdbacks during transitions.

How to verify: Ask for the current commission grid, recent amendments, and written confirmation that changes won’t be retroactive for existing transactions. Confirm payout timing and any escrowed funds policies.

Script: 'Please share the current commission grid and any pending changes. If changes are planned, will they apply to existing transaction pipelines?'

4. What training programs and mentorship pathways will continue, change, or be added?

Why this matters: Training is a direct ROI for newer agents and a retention tool for experienced teams. Leadership shifts can cut or expand training resources.

Red flags: Canceled curricula, one-time onboarding sessions instead of ongoing development, or empty promises about 'future programs.'

How to verify: Request the training calendar, trainer bios, completion metrics, and access to recordings. Ask for data on how training has led to agent productivity improvements in the past.

Script: 'Which training programs are guaranteed through Q4 2026 and what are their completion and success rates? Can I see sample syllabus and alumni results?'

5. Which technology platforms are mandatory, optional, or planned for rollout?

Why this matters: New CEOs often prioritize tech—CRM, lead routing, transaction management, AI assistants. Platform costs, data portability, and integrations affect day-to-day operations.

Red flags: Mandatory expensive platforms with no migration or data export guarantees, or duplicated tools that fragment workflows.

How to verify: Request a tech inventory: vendor names, contract lengths, agent costs, integration maps, and data ownership policies. Test platform demos and ask IT about data export procedures. If you’re unsure whether a platform is doing more harm than good, start with a vendor checklist like How to Know When Your Property Tech Stack Is Doing More Harm Than Good.

Script: 'Please provide a list of required and optional tech platforms, agent costs, and the policy for exporting data if I leave the brokerage.'

6. How will marketing dollars and lead allocation be handled?

Why this matters: Brand marketing and paid lead programs can materially affect your pipeline. New leadership may centralize marketing or change lead distribution models.

Red flags: Centralized lead hoarding, opaque lead scoring, or sudden removal of co-op marketing budgets.

How to verify: Ask for marketing spend by channel, sample lead reports, and the lead allocation policy. Confirm whether agents can buy leads and how exclusivity is managed. For thinking about which channels still deliver, compare with a 2026 benchmark of social platforms.

Script: 'How are marketing funds allocated and how are leads scored and distributed? Can agents purchase leads independently?'

7. What are the explicit career-growth paths and ownership opportunities?

Why this matters: Agents should see a path to expand—team lead roles, profit-share, equity, franchising, or brokerage ownership. Leadership change can open—or close—these options.

Red flags: No defined promotion tracks, verbal promises of equity, or pay-to-play ownership models with unclear returns.

How to verify: Request written promotion criteria, sample contracts for profit-share or equity programs, and case studies of agents who advanced under prior leadership.

Script: 'What concrete promotion pathways exist for top-performing agents and how are ownership or profit-share options structured and documented?'

8. Are agent contracts, non-competes, or policies changing? What legal protections exist?

Why this matters: Contract language affects your mobility and income. New leadership can trigger policy rewrites that limit mobility or transfer fees during conversions.

Red flags: New, restrictive non-competes, onerous transfer fees, or unilateral amendment clauses that let the brokerage change terms at will.

How to verify: Ask for copies of current and proposed contract templates. Have a real estate attorney review non-compete clauses, assignment rights, and termination penalties. If the brokerage is asking about agent identity or onboarding checks, consider whether changes to identity verification or KYC have been proposed — see general KYC and verification impacts in adjacent industries such as age-detection/KYC work.

Script: 'Please provide the agent agreement and any proposed changes. I’ll have these reviewed; what is the process and timeline for contract changes?'

9. What are the cultural and operational signals to watch for?

Why this matters: Culture determines daily work life. After leadership changes or conversions, culture shifts can be abrupt—new meeting rhythms, KPIs, performance management, and hybrid policies.

Red flags: Rapid departures of senior managers, closed-door decision-making, or public contradictions between leadership statements and agent experience.

How to verify: Talk to a cross-section of agents—senior, mid-tier, and new. Read reviews on agent forums, check LinkedIn for leadership churn, and attend a town hall or team meeting. Use recognition and retention diagnostics such as tactics in a field guide on building trust and recognition to validate cultural claims.

Script: 'Can I speak with three agents from different teams about daily operations and culture? I’m evaluating the real-world experience post-transition.'

10. Is the brokerage financially stable and transparent about funds that support agent programs?

Why this matters: Marketing funds, lead pools, office leases, and payroll for support staff all require capital. Financial instability can result in cutbacks to agent programs and delayed commission payouts.

Red flags: Delayed commission payments, unexplained reduction of marketing budgets, or refusal to explain funding for agent support programs.

How to verify: Ask for transparency on marketing fund balances, office budget allocations, and commission payout timelines. If a franchisor, request confirmation of franchise support for conversions (as with industry conversions in 2025). For visibility into payment flows and payout timing, insist the brokerage demonstrate monitoring and statements much like payments teams do with observability tools — see observability for payments.

Script: 'Can you share the structure that funds agent-facing programs and confirm commission payout timelines?'

Two real-world mini case studies from 2025–2026

Case 1: CEO appointment at a legacy brand

When Century 21 New Millennium named Kim Harris Campbell CEO in late 2025, agents watched for strategic shifts because she came from a major tech-forward competitor. The founders moved to a board role, signaling governance continuity with strategic change. Practical takeaways: ask for the CEO's roadmap and confirm which legacy programs will remain intact under new leadership.

Case 2: Large conversion into a national brand

In another 2025 example a national franchisor absorbed roughly 1,200 agents across 17 offices from regional firms. Conversions can bring scale and tools, but they also require harmonizing comp plans and tech. Agents who asked for the conversion playbook, retention data, and marketing-commitment letters had better outcomes than those who relied on verbal assurances. If you’re negotiating grandfathered comp or referral splits, refer to frameworks for structuring referral income and partnerships like How Real Estate Agents Should Structure Referral Income and Partnerships.

Practical due-diligence steps (a 7-point action plan you can use today)

1. Create a one-page memo tracking answers to the 10 questions. Use it during recruiter or manager calls.
2. Request written copies of the strategic plan, agent agreement, commission grid, and training calendar.
3. Speak to at least five current agents from different production tiers and one who left in the past 12 months.
4. Run a LinkedIn churn check for leadership and top agents over the past 18 months.
5. Get a lawyer to review contract changes, non-compete language, and conversion terms.
6. Test required tech platforms with a demo account and ask about data portability; when evaluating mandatory platforms, compare vendor behavior to the checks in cloud storage and export reviews and the tech-stack assessment in property tech stack diagnostics.
7. Negotiate protections up front: grandfathered commission terms for active deals, transition support, and written marketing commitments.

Red-flag checklist (instant scan)

• Leadership refuses to share strategic documents.
• Comp changes are announced retroactively.
• Mandatory expensive tech with no exit or data-export policy.
• Opaque lead allocation or sudden removal of co-op funds.
• Contracts with unilateral amendment clauses or new non-competes.
• Evidence of mass departures or unexplained office closures.

2026 trends that should shape your questions

Be intentional about the following trends when you vet leadership:

• AI-first tools: Many brokerages now bundle AI for lead scoring and content. Ask who owns the data and whether AI recommendations are auditable; see background on AI privacy and on-device models at Why On-Device AI Matters.
• Hybrid office models: Expect revised cost-sharing; request clarity on which offices remain leased and how support staff are funded.
• Outcome-based training: Leadership is trending toward competency-based training tied to measurable conversion metrics. Ask for outcomes, not promises.
• Consolidation & brand-attached conversions: These bring scale but also integration risk—scrutinize conversion playbooks and retention results.

Negotiation tactics agents can use

If you like the new leadership but want protections, use these tactics:

• Ask for grandfathered compensation for open transactions and a written guarantee for at least 12 months.
• Request a 'transition support package'—temporary marketing dollars, tech credits, and admin help during the first 90 days.
• Negotiate data portability clauses to ensure you can export CRM and client histories if you leave the brokerage; reference neutral storage and export practices in cloud export reviews.
• Request a probationary review at 90 and 180 days with specific KPIs tied to training and support.

Wrap-up: Make a decision that protects income and future options

Leadership changes and mass conversions can be growth opportunities. They can also hide risks. The difference is preparation. By asking focused, strategic questions and verifying answers with documents, agent interviews, and legal review, you protect your pipeline, income, and long-term career growth.

Clear, documented answers are better than charming town-hall speeches.

Next steps — a one-week checklist

1. Day 1: Request the strategic plan, commission grid, 12-month retention data, and current agent agreement.
2. Day 2–3: Call 5 agents and attend the next town hall. Book a demo of mandatory tech platforms.
3. Day 4: Send contract to an attorney for review.
4. Day 5–6: Negotiate protections (grandfathered comp, transition support, data portability).
5. Day 7: Decide and document your personal plan—stay, renegotiate terms, or start an exit strategy.

Final thought

In 2026 the fastest-moving brokerages will be those that pair bold leadership with transparent, agent-centered operations. When you vet a brokerage after a CEO appointment or mass conversion, insist on clarity and documentation. Your career depends on it.

Call to action

Need a vetting template you can use in recruiter calls and town halls? Download our free 1-page due-diligence memo or schedule a 20-minute strategy session to review answers from your brokerage. Take control of the transition: protect your deals and your future.

Related Reading

• How Real Estate Agents Should Structure Referral Income and Partnerships (Templates Included)
• How to Know When Your Property Tech Stack Is Doing More Harm Than Good
• Benchmark: Which Social Platforms Are Worth Driving Traffic From in 2026?
• Why On-Device AI Matters for Viral Apps in 2026
• How to Build a Hybrid Smart Lighting System for Historic and High-Value Homes
• How Keto Micro‑Popups and Local Testing Define Product Success in 2026
• Where Top Composers Live and Work: A Capital’s Guide to Film-Score Culture
• Curated: 12 Ceramic Home Accessories That Make Renters’ Spaces Feel High-End on a Budget
• Patch Breakdown: What Nightreign’s Changes Reveal About FromSoftware’s Design Direction